Dreaming about the same dream again
Recurring dreams are common, they are more often unpleasant than pleasant, and the useful thing about them is not their content but the fact that you have a repeated measure of something.
Also searched as: a recurring dream, i keep having this dream, the same dream every night, a returning place
Recurrence takes two forms and they are worth separating. The same narrative repeating is one; a returning place or situation with different events in it is the other, and the second is more common.
The returning place is reported with a consistency dreamers find remarkable: a house, a town, a school, described as the same each time and often as becoming more familiar.
Recurring dreams skew unpleasant. That is a real finding and it fits the wider pattern that distressing dreams are recalled and pleasant ones are not.
Many recurring dreams stop, and dreamers frequently cannot say when, which is worth knowing for anybody who feels stuck with one.
Common associations
- A repeated measure, which is what makes it useful.
- A returning place, more common than a returning story.
- A skew towards the unpleasant.
- Stopping, which happens more than people expect.
Positive readings
The practical value is real: a recurring dream is the only thing in a journal you can watch change. Log the variations and the sequence becomes visible where a single entry shows nothing.
Recurring dreams are also the easiest to become lucid in, because a familiar setting is a familiar dream sign.
Difficult readings
A distressing recurring dream is genuinely wearing, and where it follows a real trauma it is a recognised symptom rather than a curiosity.
For those, imagery rehearsal and related rescripting approaches have real evidence behind them, and that is a treatment rather than an interpretation.
Psychological perspectives
Recurrent dreams are associated with periods of stress and tend to reduce as circumstances improve, which is one of the better supported findings about them.
The returning place is more interesting and less well explained. A stable set of memory fragments reassembled the same way would produce it, which is plausible and, as far as the evidence goes, untested.
Where recurrence follows trauma, the picture is different and better understood, and the treatment literature is the relevant one.
Cultural and historical
Repeated dreams are treated as significant in a great many traditions, frequently as insistence: a message repeated because it was not heeded.
That reading gives a recurring dream more weight than a single one, and it is worth knowing that the modern evidence points at stress and circumstance rather than at emphasis.
What the sleep science says
Reasonably supported: recurrent dreams are associated with stress and tend to reduce as circumstances improve.
Well documented: rescripting and imagery rehearsal for recurrent post-traumatic nightmares.
Anecdotally reported, not tested: stable recurring dream locations with consistent geography.
Your own context
- The same story, or the same place?
- What changes between them?
- When did it start?
- Is there something it started alongside?
If this recurs
This is the entry about recurring dreams, so the advice is the whole point: log every instance with a date, and log what differed. The variation is the data, and it is invisible without a record.
Emotions often reported
- unease
- fatigue
- dread
- curiosity
- frustration
- wonder
Specific the same dream again dreams
Each of these is written separately, not generated from this page.
Where it happened
What state it was in
Questions for reflection
These are for your journal, not for us. Nothing you write is shared.
- Same story or same place?
- What was different this time?
- When did these start?
Dream interpretation is subjective. Nothing here is a diagnosis, a prediction, or medical advice.
Sources and reviewed references
4 references. What these labels mean
- 1.Clinical Management of Chronic Nightmares: Imagery Rehearsal TherapySleep medicine
Barry Krakow and Antonio Zadra (2006) · Behavioral Sleep Medicine
Cited for: That rehearsing a rewritten version of a recurring nightmare while awake reduces nightmare frequency and distress.
- 2.The Scientific Study of Dreams: Neural Networks, Cognitive Development and Content AnalysisAcademic book
G. William Domhoff (2003) · American Psychological Association
Cited for: The continuity hypothesis (that dream content largely reflects waking concerns) and a sustained critique of symbolic dream interpretation as an evidential method.
- 3.Nightmares: A New Neurocognitive ModelPeer-reviewed research
Tore Nielsen and Ross Levin (2007) · Sleep Medicine Reviews
Cited for: A model of nightmare production combining affect load and affect distress, and the distinction between bad dreams and nightmares proper.
- 4.Gender Differences in Dream Recall: A Meta-AnalysisPeer-reviewed research
Michael Schredl and Iris Reinhard (2008) · Journal of Sleep Research
Cited for: Dream-recall frequency as a measurable, individually stable trait, and the factors that move it.
Dreamers’ accounts
How dreams of the same dream again have gone for other people, in their own words. Nothing here is an interpretation of anyone else's dream. It is a record of what happened and what it was like.
Nothing here yet. Be the first to say how this has gone for you.
Related records
- PlaceCityCities in dreams are usually composites: a place assembled from several real ones, which the dreamer nonetheless names confidently as somewhere specific. That combination of accurate detail and impossible layout is the most reported feature.
- SymbolTreeTrees are reported as fixed points. Dreamers describe a single tree in a landscape, remember its position precisely, and return to it across dreams more often than to almost any other object.
- PlaceChildhood homeThe most reported dream setting there is. It usually appears altered (extra rooms, wrong layout, doors that were not there) and the alterations are more informative than the house.
- ActionKnowing you are dreamingLucid dreaming is one of the few things in this entire database that has been demonstrated in a laboratory rather than inferred from reports. Sleepers have signalled from inside a dream with prearranged eye movements, on cue, while verifiably asleep.
- ActionRefusingDreamers almost never refuse anything, and that is the finding. This database is full of dreamers complying with absurd instructions, accepting impossible situations and answering to wrong names, and an entry for the exception is the right way to end.
- ActionA gameGames in dreams have rules the dreamer does not know and cannot ask about, and everybody else appears to know them. That structure is the clearest statement of something the first-day, examination and competition entries each describe in part.
Records that mention the same dream again
These pages link to the same dream again, either as something reported in the same dream or as a related subject. This page does not point back at all of them, so the list is assembled rather than chosen.